知识卡片
新意与明显缺陷应分别处理
有新意但存在关键缺陷的工作,可能值得先解决缺陷再投稿;只有小幅改进的完整工作则需重新审视贡献价值。缺陷是否影响核心主张比是否容易被看见更重要,不能只修表面问题掩盖实质错误。
这张卡片看不懂?
这张卡片已通过人工审查,不再接受失败反馈。
已有反馈 · 0 条
还没有人提交反馈。
在整书笔记中的位置
- · 如何写论文
原书出处 · 1 处
- · 查看原书依据
At the other end of the spectrum of borderline papers are “puppies with six toes.” These are delightful papers, but with an easy-to-see flaw. The flaw may not matter (like six toes on a puppy) but makes the paper easy to reject, even though the paper may be fresh and wonderful. Maybe two-thirds of those papers get rejected, and one-third maybe accepted as posters. As
参考来源
- 位置:《Foundations of Computer Vision (Antonio Torralba, Phillip Isola etc.)》第53章《如何写论文》(来源项目:a19c7933-4eda-4176-aebd-30fe7e1ad292;源文件:extracted/Foundations of Computer Vision (Antonio Torralba, Phillip Isola etc.)/_epub-src/OPS/xhtml/c053.xhtml)
- 结论依据:摘录中关于新意与明显缺陷应分别处理的定义、比较或条件支撑卡片;原书表述不严谨的范围已在覆盖记录逐项限定,不把案例结果外推为普遍结论。
- 原始内容:At the other end of the spectrum of borderline papers are “puppies with six toes.” These are delightful papers, but with an easy-to-see flaw. The flaw may not matter (like six toes on a puppy) but makes the paper easy to reject, even though the paper may be fresh and wonderful. Maybe two-thirds of those papers get rejected, and one-third maybe accepted as posters. As