知识卡片
架构与设计处于连续谱
架构偏向系统结构,设计偏向具体实现与呈现,但许多决策处于两者之间。可用三项线索判断其位置:
- 决策偏长期战略还是短期战术;
- 建立或改变它需要多少投入;
- 收益与代价会影响多大范围。
原书以从分层单体迁到微服务和调整界面字段位置作两端例子。三项都是判断线索,不是硬性分类;团队仍需结合具体场景确定谁负责该决策。与[[多数架构选择存在连续谱]]相呼应。
这张卡片看不懂?
这张卡片的反馈已满 10 条,暂时无法继续提交。
已有反馈 · 0 / 10 条
还没有人提交反馈。
在整书笔记中的位置
原书出处 · 1 处
- Architectural Thinking · 查看原书依据
Unfortunately, most decisions such as these fall somewhere on a spectrum between architecture and design, making it difficult to determine what should be considered architecture. Leveraging the following criteria can help determine whether something is more about architecture or more about design: Is it more strategic in nature or more tactical? How much effort will it take to change or construct? How significant are the trade-offs?
参考来源
- 位置:《Fundamentals of Software Architecture》第04章《Architectural Thinking》(源文件:`OEBPS/ch02.html`,Architecture Versus Design、Strategic Versus Tactical Decisions、Level of Effort、The Significance of Trade-Offs)
- 结论依据:原文明确称大多数决策落在架构与设计之间,随后逐项讨论战略性、变更投入与权衡显著性;两个例子为原书举例。
- 原始内容:Unfortunately, most decisions such as these fall somewhere on a spectrum between architecture and design, making it difficult to determine what should be considered architecture. Leveraging the following criteria can help determine whether something is more about architecture or more about design: Is it more strategic in nature or more tactical? How much effort will it take to change or construct? How significant are the trade-offs?