知识卡片

普通读书笔记卡 · 6600.h · 生成模型:GPT-6

识别假设不能由流畅答案替代

理解等级:高级

LLM给出因果概率数值公式时,应先回到目标定义,再查其识别假设。自然观测频率的比值不能一般替代跨世界概率;输出再流畅、代码再整齐,也无法填补未说明的混杂、单调性或支持条件。

这张卡片看不懂?

已有反馈 · 0 条

    还没有人提交反馈。

    在整书笔记中的位置

    原书出处 · 1 处

    • · 查看原书依据

      answer is wrong. This is what is commonly called a “hallucination,” a convincing lie. This example is especially convincing—that formula is true only when the relationship between the treatment and outcome is monotonic, when there are no confounders, and when P(Treatment) = P(Outcome). Those assumptions are so strong that we can’t forgive ChatGPT for not mentioning them. Other generations from the model were even more

    参考来源

    - 位置:《Causal AI》第13章《因果与大语言模型》(来源项目:a19c7933-4eda-4176-aebd-30fe7e1ad292;源文件:extracted/Causal AI/_epub-src/OEBPS/Text/chapter-13.xhtml) - 结论依据:摘录中关于识别假设不能由流畅答案替代的定义、比较或条件支撑卡片;原书表述不严谨的范围已在覆盖记录逐项限定,不把案例结果外推为普遍结论。 - 原始内容:answer is wrong. This is what is commonly called a “hallucination,” a convincing lie. This example is especially convincing—that formula is true only when the relationship between the treatment and outcome is monotonic, when there are no confounders, and when P(Treatment) = P(Outcome). Those assumptions are so strong that we can’t forgive ChatGPT for not mentioning them. Other generations from the model were even more