知识卡片
总体规划可因过硬与过虚同时失效
作者引用建筑师 Christopher Alexander 团队对校园总体规划的批评:整体布局被预先锁定,难以适应社区的意外变化;具体建筑之间的连接又规定得不够,难以指导局部设计。
原书借此类比软件战略:需要全员可用、能在逐步增长中维持整体秩序的原则,而非预先固定每个局部的“总图”。这是引用的城市规划论证,不是软件项目的实测结论。
这张卡片看不懂?
这张卡片已通过人工审查,不再接受失败反馈。
已有反馈 · 0 条
还没有人提交反馈。
在整书笔记中的位置
原书出处 · 1 处
- 原书第17章|Six Essentials for Strategic Design Decision Making · 查看原书依据
And even to the extent that master plans are followed . . . they do not specify enough about connections between buildings, human scale, balanced function, etc. to help each local act of building and design become well-related to the environment as a whole.
参考来源
- 位置:《Domain-Driven Design: Tackling Complexity in the Heart of Software》第140章《Six Essentials for Strategic Design Decision Making》(源文件:_epub-src/0321125215_ch17lev1sec5.html)
- 结论依据:原书引用The Oregon Experiment对总体规划过于僵硬且细节不足的批评,并总结以共同原则支持渐进增长。
- 原始内容:They are too rigid; they cannot easily adapt to the natural and unpredictable changes that inevitably arise in the life of a community. [...] And even to the extent that master plans are followed . . . they do not specify enough about connections between buildings, human scale, balanced function, etc. to help each local act of building and design become well-related to the environment as a whole. [...] Thus, as a source of organic order, a master plan is both too precise, and not precise enough. The totality is too precise: the details are not precise enough. [...] Alexander and his colleagues advocated instead a set of principles for all community members to apply to every act of piecemeal growth, so that "organic order" emerges, well adapted to circumstances.
- 转录说明:前三段摘录为原书再引 *The Oregon Experiment*,最后一段是 Evans 在引文后的总结,`[...]` 标明非连续位置及再引文到作者总结的转换;本卡避开原 EPUB 的异常破折号字节。软件战略应用是作者的类比,不是建筑规划材料的软件实验结论。