知识卡片
建议要包含支撑理由
建议同时给出方向与为什么:发生过什么、在何种条件下奏效、有哪些代价。单说“更快、更便宜、质量更好”仍只是缺少证据的意见。决定者可以问为什么及如何,让隐含经验显露,再判断它是否适用于当前环境;理由比建议者的地位更有助于迁移。
这张卡片看不懂?
这张卡片的反馈已满 10 条,暂时无法继续提交。
已有反馈 · 0 / 10 条
还没有人提交反馈。
在整书笔记中的位置
原书出处 · 1 处
- The Architecture Advice Process · 查看原书依据
When advice is offered, we get both the direction recommendation and the reasons behind it—the benefits of experience. That means the advice recipients get the advisers’ perspectives and perceived outcomes that a potential course of action may or may not lead to. That can truly be incorporated into the decision process. For example, some advice
参考来源
- 位置:《Facilitating Software Architecture》第04章《The Architecture Advice Process》(来源项目 /Users/wangyi/claudecodeProject/bookBase/book-sources;源文件:extracted/Facilitating Software Architecture/_epub-src/OEBPS/ch04.html)
- 结论依据:原文以OpenJDK选型对比advice与opinion,指出why使decider能辨别适用情境。
- 原始内容:When advice is offered, we get both the direction recommendation and the reasons behind it—the benefits of experience. That means the advice recipients get the advisers’ perspectives and perceived outcomes that a potential course of action may or may not lead to. That can truly be incorporated into the decision process. For example, some advice